Include

[flavirufus]

Originally Posted by ad

He should clarify his statements if questioned - if he is basing them on scientific study let us know.

Hi Adam,

Of course he's not basing it on a scientific study! If we had to carry out a scientific study before we shared our thoughts on anything about reptile keeping, we'd be living in near complete ignorance. No one's asking Dave to provide scientific evidence for any of his claims regarding wild caught animals and nor should we either.

There are however some wonderful studies on selective breeding (no, they're not on reptiles, yes, they are applicable to reptiles) that clearly demonstartive that behavioural characteristics can be selected for. Therefore, there is a scientific basis for Simon's claims. I haven't seen the '1st generation hatchies v multi generation hatchies' staement other than in these threads, but this would still hold true if selective pressure have been applied (either by passive or active selection).

It's possible Simon will be elaborating on his thoughts in future magazine articles. Given the debate seems to have arisen because of past articles, that seems like an appropriate forum.

Regards,
Matt