I love the thermostat debate, it's like arguing whether you should swim freestyle or backstroke to cross a river. At the end of the day your goals are the same.
ANY approach to heating an enclosure needs to be properly considered, researched and tested prior to permanently housing an animal. I'm sure if you searched through all the threads on this forum (or any other for that matter) there would be a laundry list of stories from people who have blindly followed advice and ended up with a problem.
Fundamentally, you want:
- a warm end that allows the reptile to get its BODY TEMPERATURE up to its preferred optimal temperature. In order to do this the basking site may well need to be warmer, particularly for exposed tubs that rely on heat mats.
- a cool end that is not influenced by the temperature of the warm end. This can be done through extra space or dividers.
- a portion of the enclosure that remains below the critical thermal maximum (i.e. death temperature) for the reptile housed regardless of circumstances. If you use a thermostat, this should account for thermostat failure on an uncharacteristically hot day. If you aren't using a thermostat, this involves seasonally changing the heating mechanism (e.g. changing globes in Summer). Dividers can assist with this.
The options that exist within these requirements are varied and well documented, just understand the full picture before blindly taking advice. You'll probably find that once the person offering the advice knows the full details of your setup, the response would be "yeah that won't work, you need to .....".