alot of the time it does the opposite, the dog pulls to escape the pain inflicted by these collars, Mind if i put one of them around your neck and then pull with all of my body weight to 'control' you? Point is most people do not know how to use them, and being readily available to the public is stupid.
There is no excuse for a dog to be aggressive, and there is no excuse to not have a dog walk on the lead and be able to control it.
Oh and most people use them as a choke collar, but with the additive of metal prongs.
My opinion; They are cruel and if a dog can be trained to walk normally on a lead (which ALL of them can) there is no need for a prong collar to begin with.
they will not continue to pull with a prong unless they are desensitized too it which would'nt happen if used properly.
you dont use your body weight to pull with any type of collar. that is miss treating the dog and is an incorrect way to train a dog.
I have tried one around my neck and I used a choke on my self too and I would take the prong anyday.
I agree on how it is stupid that they are readily avaiable to the public without the proper knowledge and training how to use one. same with chokes, haltis and martingales aswell.
there is aggressive dogs. abusive owners are the main contributors but there are other factors that can trigger aggression in dogs aswell like poor breeding, poor sociallizing. there are many types of aggression in dogs like fear aggression, territorial aggression, dominant aggression, predatorial aggession.
the prong collar can't be used as a choke because its a limited slip collar, which means it only tightens to a certain point and then cant be tightened any more, so i don't know where you got that myth from.
not all dogs can be trained to walk on a leash properly with a normal flat collar, if they could there would be no reason for any other collar to exsist. your world sounds grand and I wish it were true but the fact is its not. pull your head out of the sand and have a look at the real world. plus the dogs learn quicker using the prong, hence the process is alot less stressful for you and the dog than tugging and dragging the dog around on a flat collar for weeks. very frustrating and not fun for the dog.
you still haven't answered what you use to train a large dominant dog with?