Aussie Pythons & Snakes Forum

Help Support Aussie Pythons & Snakes Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Status
Not open for further replies.
obee what zoo are we talking about? and i dont have any experience with gtp's and neither do most people on this site but when and if you start a waiting list for those gtp's make sure you pm me with what will happen and how much they will be sold for?

Thanks heaps Rick
 
Obee,

Just one more thing. I have 40 years experience with reptiles and just on 20 years with Aussie Greens. I had no intention posting to this thread, matter of fact did not even know it was going on. But when Ad posted something I had written ages ago and you discredited what I had written,I was advised by friends to read this post and to reply.

Not once did I personally attack you, I just quoted the truth which is something you do not want other people to hear. And yet you try to discredit my knowledge, you imply I have bad dealings with people and then try to insult me personally.

I only have one thing to say to you OBee Very PETTY & CHILDISH
 
hey bob your a lucky man to have had gtp's for over 20 years. how old is your oldest one?
 
The way you explain things Bob :) that makes alot of sence to me, i had been told by many people that they were aussie, i had my doubts as you had told me about it a while back but them someone said they had been deemed aussie by NPWS, but in fact they had been deemed legal PNGs.

One thing thats i'm not sure of is you say that any breeding from that line can be legally sold and held as they were proved to be legally imported but didn't NPWS say that legal exotics weren't allowed to be bred?

I don't like this thread it's making me nervous :shock:
 
Sxe

I know of only 7 legally held Greens in Australia. Five were bred by Rob Bredl 20 years ago, and Steve Irwin had 2 in his collection when I was last there in 1995. I believe Steve bred his back then, hatching about 7, but I also heard they died.

John Oshea illegally gave Steve Irwin Bob Buckleys breeding Greens while his court cases were still pending. This was against the law to do so. The courts have ordered the return of his breeders to Buckley, but Irwin is refusing to release them as he claim Oshea gave them to him.

I believe Irwin has actually bred from Buckleys breeders, but Sxe, these are not true Aussie Greens. There has never been an all blue Green found in Australia yet. A few females have had a few blue patches on their bodies no bigger then 5cm , but thats it.
 
Alright, cool. I know Steve has received other confiscated Chondro's too.
 
No one,

NSW NPWS will not allow the breeding of exotics held on a prohibited licence that were claimed on the amnesty here in NSW. Buckleys Greens are on standard reptile keepers licences, therefore they are legal to breed and can not be confiscated.

If I was to buy any Greens being bred in Australia these days, I would make sure they were Tims or any bred from his young. These may not be Australian, but are definately legal and can not be confiscated by the authorites as these are the only ones that were legally imported. $5000 to $7000 is a lot to risk from other breeders as they could be subject to consfication from the federal govt
 
Blue Streak,

It would have to be the Rough Scale Python which is now being bred by the Aust Reptile Pk
 
Hey Bigguy, Is it true that Steve Irwin testified as an expert witness in a QLD court that reptiles are genetically programmed to grow a a set rate & you can't make them grow any faster by feeding them more?
 
Buggie,

Yes, you are 100% correct. According to Steve Irwin( the reptile expert), reptiles growth rates are not effected by food in any way and no matter how much food you give them, they will not grow any faster. They will only get fatter like overfeeding a human child He also stated it was impossible to breed small monitors, because he and his father could not after 10 years of trying . His statements are all recorded in court transcripts for anyone to research and read.
 
Blue Streak

There has only ever been a handful found to this day. The Reptile Park, after years of trips, finally found where they lived. After years of negotiations with Calm, they were finally given permission to collect a small breeding colony. John weigel is now breeding from these origional specimens and the young are slowly being given to major Australian Zoos.

Maybe, in another 10 years or so, John will be able to give to the public. Well lets hope so anyway.
 
big guy this is the thing i'm having trouble grasping.. you say you were breeding gtp the same time as bob. if so where are the prodgeny from these breedings.? if they infact actually happened how can you say there are no other lines of aussie gtp in this country.? after all you have said yours were some of the only ones, so offspring from them would surely be in oz also.i heard when they were taken from you ended up getting 2 males back so how did you produce from them and you never said anything.mmm
with all due respect to you and what you have done bob. there really is only two people in this country worth taking to with regards of practical gtp results. tim from ultimate reptiles for husbandry as his results speak for themselves. and david william on the study that he has been doing for a long time now. and frankly we haven't seen many results from you with this species todate and ad running off at the mouth like he does really is funny.i've noticed he has become very quiet on this all of a sudden.
i did not discredit the truth on the cut and paste of yours that ad posted. i just highlighted the fact that in the discussion you stated aussie gtp don't have blue on them but after you were sent a pick that david williams had taken in the iron range you now say they do, which is it bob?you should of asked me even i could have told you that,guess you couldn't find it in any book , the problem there lies in the fact like already said , that only half of the discussion was used by ad and held little if any relevance to this discussion.
bob you wrote......(Geez Obee, you convinced me. Of coarce you are the expert on Greens as you have kept them 17 months. As you said i dont know everything and I am wrong on this instance. Or could it be i have known Bob Buckley for 20 years and have shared breeding details with him over this time as we were both breeding Greens for that same period.) ......
.if you bothered to take notice of what i wrote i was talking to ad about being proven wrong as he is the one thats offered to pay for the d.n.a test. thats why i wrote ( prove yourself wrong.. if directed at the both of you i would have wrote prove you both wrong.) it was your decision to get involved with the thread after all as im sure the big guy wouldnt be told what to do.
anyway on that note its just a matter of time before we receive the receipt for the payment of the d.n.a. test as ad offered in a public forum then we will be happy to have the results published for all to view as they will be returned the same as the others.( deemed australian) the key word and the one we always use is DEEMED.

my understanding is that not all of bob animals came from taronga zoo and some of the animals he had were infact oz gtp and yes the parents of ours did have suspect blood from the same race with the same indistinguishable dna in their back ground.think about it bob.

if ad has infact posted my pic on an american site for them to past judgement please post the link to the dicussion so we can all see it.
if in fact this hasn't happened before this week you may also like to admit you are wrong on this as well.

the bootom line is that we stated they are deemed to be ozgtp by dna sampling. the are advertised on ultimates site as the cape york ( merauke) race as they are described in the book. both you and i know that the dna of both southern png and oz gtp is to hard to split.i suppose you think that gene flow doesn't occur between sth png,torres strait and the cape then.

on the matter of attacking you personally. im picking your refering to the referance of your user name. i guess you dont have the same sense of humour as some of us. but think about it a little.. THE BIG GUY. would get the same sort of jives if i used a user name like Best reptile breeder and im sure you would be one of the first to comment on the statment made from the use of a user name like that as i did with yours.


obee
 
Obee,

You ask about my breedings and also question there reliablity. Well I can assure you, I had two clutches of Greens from my pair from Rob Bredl. Out of these I GAVE, yes thats right, gave at no cost, over a dozen to some of my friends. I kept the remaining for my own colony. So weres all my progeny you ask. Well ask John Osea of the Queensland Fauna Squad. His mission in life was to have all Greens confiscated so no one would have any.

Just after Buckley's were seized, Oshea then came after mine. After a huge raid at my dwelling Osea had all my Greens taken, and then confiscated all those I had given away to my friends. I had 18 adults at the time of the raid. All went to Taronga, as well as Buckleys 27 hatchlings, plus a dozen that were seized coming into Brisbane from overseas and in a period of 2 years over 60 Greens died at Taronga Zoo.

They also tried to have Tims siezed in SA, but SA NPWS would not have a bar of it, luckerly.

In 1997, I was finally returned what was left. Two males, one which was my male from Rob Bredl, the other a PNG male that had my females microchip in it. Someone at the Zoo had swapped my snake for an exotic. It was also widely known that this same Taronga keeper was in fact selling Buckley's hatchlings for a thousand each. An investigation was made and it was found over half of the alledged dead greens were unaccounted for at the zoo.

This was the end of my breeding Aussie Greens, so Oshea got his wish. You can read about my trouble with Oshea in Hosers book, Smuggled 2. If Oshea had not siezed my 18 adult Greens, I would have bred literally hundreds by now and the price would have been around $1000, not the huge amount that is now being asked for them at present.

As for you saying I am wrong about Ad stating your Green pictures were seen by over 30 US breeders who identified them as PNG's, I refer you to read back to page 3 or 4 of this thread were he clearly states those facts. Am I wrong in stating whats on this thread. I think not again.

As for Buckley's origional breeding. He only had two greens to start with. Try not to infer he may have had several others as well as the Taronga PNG .

Now for your DNA evidence. You are correct. Aussie Greens and Southern PNGS are nearly the same, with not enough difference to put up a 100% legal aguement in court. So how does that prove yours is Australian or PNG. It doesnt prove either way. You can not prove your is either an Australian or PNG. Arn't we lucky however, that it appears every photo taken of an Australian Green, as well as every one collected in the past and at the present by David Wilson(not Williams) have all shown to have the same basic colouration. Even the 5 females Wilson found with the few Blue blotches still shared the basic colouration and markings.

Tims and yours, Obee, are the only Australians that do not share this common colour and marking trait. In fact they are identical to the markings and colour of the PNG Greens. Could this mean that Buckley was not lying when he testified in court that he had bred from the Taronga Zoo PNG specimem, hense the PNG colouring. Or are we to believe you that Buckley was mistaken, that the 30 US herps that Ad mentioned are also wrong and do not know what they are talking about,that even though yours do match pic's in Maxwells book that it is wrong also, and that after all my involvement with Aussie Greens and my knowledge of Buckley that I am also mistaken.It seems to me that the mounting evidence tends to lean towards the fact that you may be mistaken with your claim of Aussie Greens.

Why did Queensland NPWS allow you to keep yours on a specialist licence. Simple. Buckley beat them in court and yours are decendants of his.
 
Hi Obee,
There is no need for any comment from me, but if you insist....

You, with minimal-years reptile keeping experience - 17 months with greens - arguing with someone with 40 years keeping experience -20 years experience with the pythons discussed.

Facts backed with experience - Or -your 'research before you handed over your $30k'

Sounds like a kid in a go-kart telling brocky how to drive bathurst.

It appears you have legal-kept png gtps, not true aussies - please let it be the last time we hear you advertising ' true aussie' greens. please refer to the as 'legal png greens', that will clear up these discussions in the future and not confuse the gullible.

I would prefer to keep discussion to the animals, not mocking peoples usernames, but like that kid in the go-kart - its the only place for your arguement to head.
Kind Regards
Ad
 
20 yrs breeding,2 clutches,18 adults.nothing you say adds up mate,tim bred more than that in one year.VERY UNSUCCESSFUL 20 YRS I WOULD SAY.
at know stage did i say pure 100% aussie why would i.i said deemed australian ,as the line is advertised as CAPE YORK[MERAUKE]RACE as stated by the gtp bible you often refer to.so guide me bob are my animals ioo% pure sth png? or are they what we say they are.
its easy to say your prices would be lower now bob you have no animals.sounds a bit coulda,shoulda,woulda but never did.
look at the middle photo of my animal a good representation of it's green colouration.compare it to the photo of the animal you posted wow, what you know same colour green, oh and is that blue on your animal.so if i believed what you originally said then i would say yours is sth png cause it has blue.come on mate you might baboozal most but not all.
oh there you are ad,steppin out from behind uncle bob.still waiting for the RECEIPT and the LINK mate.you are obviously on the back foot and for the record i would love to sit in a cart next to brocky.i guess when you fork out the money for the test.the test will reveal you still won't be able to call the greens what you want,pure sth png.because they are what they are.pretend all you want as i said earlier jealousy is a curse ad.


obee
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top